That's pretty close to the way I see them...
Strange, you're a New Jersey fan.
Kidd's one of the top two point guards in the league this season, but I have to give the overall edge to Baron Davis. B-Diddy's taken his teams to two more wins, and the Hornets have quality wins against the Lakers, Portland, and Kidd's New Jersey. The Hornets have lost to teams they shouldn't have, like Chicago, but so have all the other teams in the NBA. The Nets are leading their division, but it's a weaker division, so that doesn't really mean much; if New Orleans were in the same division, they would be winning the division.
As for a head to head comparison this season, Kidd has him statistically, but not by much. The difference in those stats, though, are primarily in the assists, free throws, and rebounds. Kidd doesn't have the likes of Robert Traylor, Jamaal Magloire, and PJ Brown in the front court; he has Kenyon Martin, Jason Collins, Aaron Williams, and Richard Jefferson. Kidd's always been a good rebounder, but then again, he's always been on a team with no real inside...he had Mourning for a little while, but I don't think that counts.
The assists...I can't fully comment on because I've only seen one or two hornets games this year, so I don't know how they generally play; however, I know that Kidd and the Nets are great on the break, so that generally allows for more assists, especially for a point guard with vision, ball handling, and passing ability of Kidds. But like Kidd had no real post presence on his teams, his teams were built to run, and the players he played/plays with thrive in transition. Baron Davis and the Hornets play more of a half court game, from the little bit I can see, and knowning somewhat the way Tim Floyd coaches, I can see that.
In no way am I knocking Kidd's skills, because they're there, but I don't think he's the best point guard in the league this year, or ever. While he's a great passer, a great defender, and a smart player, a lot of his statisical success stems from the type of system that he's been present in...he's always been with players who could run and jump...
Of course, like your little numbers, what I just wrote was completely objective...