what if you don't want to delete the settings file? I'm having same issue. I have 3 VIP's on 2k9, one for my brother against me, one for me against my brother, & the other one is for my games against CPU....today when I went to play him & we had 2 controllers on, it didn't allow us to select the 2 we wanted, so I had to turn a 3rd controller on....I'm sure there is a solution, probably a basic one....even loading VIP didn't work....any help on basic query would be appreciated
