Ray Allen or Michael Redd?

[Silas]

Ray Allen hands down, he's twice as consistent as Redd and he's proven he can lead a team much better. He's one of the best players in the NBA and is a much more proven and better guard than Redd.

[TSquared]

the only way its a contest is if both of them have the same experience in the league.. But i go with red coz ray has more experience in the league than redd yet they both are at the same average of 39.5%.. redd isn't in his prime yet..

[Metsis]

Redd came into the league from nowhere... He was a late second round pick and just got it on in Milwaukee... And as Stein uses this comment all too frequently... Us lefties have to keep a unified front. Redd it is... I love the underdogs and guys who aren't thought much of early on, but turn out to be better players than 90% of their draft class... And Redd is a typical one of those.

[TSquared]

damn right

[Slamduncan]

I love the underdogs and guys who aren't thought much of early on, but turn out to be better players than 90% of their draft class

I agree, Redd and Arenas are both in the same boat

[1CenT]

Allen and Redd are amazing, Allen is a deadlier shooter in my opinion, i think Redd is a better scorer.
Redd is developing into more of a wing player that has a really strong shot.
Allen to me, is just the purest shooter that also has athleticism and ball handling and passing skills, kind of like Mike Miller.
Redd is a really good defender, he looks like he has a lot of passion, while Allen is those stone cold deadly shooters.

I'll pick Redd , he seems like a better leader, if you talk about shooting, i think Allen is better

[Silas]

Anyone who picks Redd is silly

[Drex]

Why? Because you say so? Because you're from Seattle and have an unbiased opinion?

[shadowgrin]

Anyone who idolizes a stiff like Korver is silly.

[ronaldo_VII]

allen for sure

[Ty-Land]

Being a Buck fan I have liked both players, but I think the Redd of this year is slightly better scorer than Allen at his peak. Redd has been driving a lot more this year, and ever since Coach K took over (before his knee problems flaring up again) his passing was much more effective as well as his D.

[shadowgrin]

Even last year Redd had a higher FTA than Allen, meaning he's been driving more to the basket.

[mAgoTT50]

ray ray