Riot wrote:The All-NBA Teams are for the best PLAYERS who had the BEST SEASON. Duncan is on a better team but Garnett had the better individual year.
to me there is no distinction. I would hardly call a player who didn't make the playoffs succesful.
The Spurs aren't better than the Wolves because of Duncan, they are better because they have the best coaching staff in the league along with the deepest team in the league.
excuse me, but the spurs ARE a better team because of duncan. Tell me exactly where pop was before duncan became a spur. Was he a good coach? yes, but nowhere near the coach he is perceived as today. I am not trying to take credit away from pop.... he is a good coach, and duncan is lucky to have him, but to discredit duncan because of him is as ridiculous as discrediting mj because he had phil.
Garnett put up some great stats, his team wasn't in the playoffs but what do you expect when you have a rookie head coach and no talent? Marko Jaric is too slow and too stupid to be a starting point guard, McCants struggled early on, Wally couldn't get his own shot and the team has no inside presence besides Garnett. Not to discredit Tim Duncan but he did not have a very good year. He was obviously bothered by that foot injury all season long.
if individual stats were the be all and end all marbury would be a perrenial first team, at worst 2nd team, all star every year (save this one). Winning percentage is as much and important a stat as ppg. Any mediocore player can put up good to great stats on a crap team.... see zach randolph..... its what those players do on a good team that define them. to be fair it is obvious garnett has an inferior cast relative to td, but all that is a hypothetical. You can't credit people for what they COULD be, and what they MIGHT do.... only for what they are. that said, imo the spurs would have never won a championship, or at least not as many, if td and kg were switched.
that said kg being left off at least the third team is a crime, and to a lesser degree I think td not being listed as c and making the first team one too.