EG wrote:First, there's the matter of physical talent. Kobe doesn't jump quite as high as Mike used to (About a 38" vert compared to Mike's 42") and Kobe has shorter arms.
Since when anyone need to jump higher than others to be considered better than those?, I don't think Olajuwon's jump was that high and that doesn't make him worse than C. Barkley who maybe had a higher jump.
You don't need to jump higher than anyone or have longer arms to be considered better than others.
EG wrote:Also...the three-point shot can be both a blessing and a curse. For evidence...compare Vince Carter before and after he learned an outside jump shot.
3pt & outside shooting is always a blessing, why? cause is something every SG should show they're capable of. If Vince is shooting from outside is to shut the mouth to those that were saying that he had no shooting ability and it might be better so he doesn't have to get injured again.
EG wrote:After Vince learned to hit the three-point shot he actually became less effective as a scorer.
Is Vince's shooting percentage bad? No. I don't think the 3s are the reason for him not to be that great scorer, look at his injuries, maybe that will explain those to you.
EG wrote:Finally...there's the matter of mentality...being a dominating scorer alone doesn't make you great. Jordan didn't reach his peak...and couldn't beat the Pistons...until he learned to pass the ball. Kobe hasn't established that mentality yet as he's had Shaq drawing the attention and doing the passing for him. That might stunt his growth in that department.
You are lost EG. That's right, MJ couldn't win until he learned to pass but figure out something, why would you say Kobe hasn't established that mentality?, I agree that Shaq is drawing the attention but that doesn't mean Kobe hasn't learned to pass the ball, when kobe has decided to keep the ball like Jordan did, Lakers have lost. I believe the Lakers have won the last 3 championships, would that be cause Kobe decided to handle the ball? Notice that Kobe is smarter since he understood he had to share with Shaq to win a long time ago, MJ didn't learn that til he spent 7 years in the league.
EG wrote:From hearing them both speak...I also personally think that Michael has a few IQ points over Kobe as well...and I've had this opinion supported by reading reports
Your IQ has nothing to do with it either since you can score 100 points and being stupid at the same time.
You have to remember that Kobe didn't go to college like Jordan did. Plus, if you think Jordan's IQ is just few points over Kobe, I give the merits to Kobe since he didn't go to college and is almost as good in general subjects as others that spent 4 years there.