by Eugene on Thu Jan 10, 2008 10:50 am
You're right. He did.
ALFA, I think what Benji is getting at, and a point that I agree with, is that religion is something you have to experience.
There is a difference between "knowing" and "believing." Knowing is when you consider something to be true because it has been proven, i.e. I know gravity exists, I know 1 + 1 equals 2, and I know Kobe Bryant has 3 less rings that Michael Jordan.
Believing, on the other hand, is when you consider something to be true without proof--I believe Kobe Bryant is a better offensive player than Michael Jordan, I believe in true love, et al...
...which is what religion and any belief system is about. You can't "know" a religion, you have to "believe" it. You can't know God, because we can't prove he exists. You believe God exists, for whatever reason personal and sacred to you. That's what we call faith.
I know it says in the Bible (I can't remember where or the specific quote, but I KNOW it's there) that God asks us to believe in him without having proof. The ability to believe something solely because of intrisic motivation is the essence of religion and faith.
From where, then, does the motivation come? Most commonly, I think, it's passed down in the family. The cynic in me says most religious people (people who go to church, mosque, temple, whatever) aren't actually faithful, but if you grow up with parents who believe God exists, chances are you're likely to, too.
Rarely (too, rarely, I think), though, some people actually experience religion. Whether real or imagined, they experience something that compels them to believe. It could be a near death experience or similar life altering events, or even something simple. Those people are different--you can absolutely tell that they understand having faith is a completely unique and personal experience (thus likely not to try to force their religion on you) and they are committed to what they believe. And they are able to commit to living their life according to their belief system, which I personally find to be admirable.
The question now becomes, can a theoretical and theological discourse lead to someone "getting" religion? Maybe. I don't think so. You have to deal with too many inconsistencies in the religious texts, and a lot of semantics, which makes the pros and cons list seem really arbitrary and obtuse. It's not like you're trying to decide on which car to buy...
And it's certainly not smart to ask for help in this forum where you're more likely to get a sarcastic or pseudo-humorous response than something actually helpful.
I do hope that you find what you're looking for. I believe having faith and religion can give you a great deal of mental and emotional strength. On that point, I don't think it matter WHAT you believe, only that you do, in fact, believe in something. But asking around here, in my opinion, is not the best way to go about this. Try to find something real. Go out an get struck by lightning or something. Survive an airplane crash. Fall in love. Whatever. Just experience something real.
The task of the artist is to translate for us the essence of things we take for granted.