carmello anthony or lebron james

[keithpetty]

who will have the better 2nd year player in 2004-2005 nba season lebron james or carmello anthony. i believe it will be lebron james because he is determine to make it to the playoffs and all star game and show the world why he was the rookie of the year last season.

[Rens]

Goddamn man can you stop making threads!! There's what 50 threads with your name on it on the first page all on a different player.. ugh..

[MikeBibby]

Goddamn man can you stop making threads!! There's what 50 threads with your name on it on the first page all on a different player.. ugh..

most likey carmelo.........but they both in the olympics so they working there game out good playing againest top ball players in the world lebron been doing his thing there i think these are the stats holla at me tell me what u think its jsut a guess

lebron james

24.5
6.8
5.9

carmelo
25.5
6.9
2.9

[Old School Fool]

Keith.............

[Rens]

Old School Fool that smiley is like a 70s vacuum cleaner. It sucks and it's ugly.

[FanOfAll]

I'll take LBJ...

[Jackal]

LeBron for me too, I don't know. I just dislike Carmelo, he looks like a guy I once had a fight with.

[.]

Talent wise for the future I take LeBron James,

But if I want to win now, I take Melo.

[Amphatoast]

Talent wise for the future I take LeBron James,

But if I want to win now, I take Melo.

question was their stats for this coming season, not future or win now

[.]

Oh ok, I pick Melo

[VCFAN]

I seriously would take Dwayne Wade on my team over either one of these guys. Lebron will probably have a better next season though. Wade has a higher field goal percentage and put up great stats on a team with already good people like eddie jones, and lamar odom but this is just my opinion.

[Riot]

LeBron has his own gatorade flavor. I'll take my own flavor over a candy bar.

[Amphatoast]

lol, next year if Wade stats are good I'm sure haters will start saying "wade has shaq" and all the other stuff people said about kobe relating to shaq.

[.]

The difference is that they wont win championships.

[Mikki]

Please stop the 'OR' threads.

[Andrew]

I'd take LeBron James as he seems to be the more well-rounded player, the better athlete and the player who still has the most potential. Melo obviously had more success in his rookie season as far as his team's record goes, but the Cavs overhauled their roster (and finished fairly strong) and the Nuggets had a better team.

[Fresh8]

Lebron will do better... He won't score as much as Melo but he'll get more assists and probably rebounds. He'll be able to dish off to Luke Jackson this year- who is a great shooter (He's also gonna play more PG this year) and also have to be able to help out on the boards... with Booze out- even though Gooden is in town.

Melo will score more than Bron this year...I think. Cause with the Nuggets decent frontcourt...teams will be trying to contain them. Melo should be going one-on-one against ther players and with his new found 20 pounds of muscle (?) and playing more 2 gurad...he should do well on the stat sheet.

I predict:

Melo: 24ppg, 5rpg, 3.2apg
Bron: 22ppg, 6rpg, 5apg

Are they overrated?

[Jay-Peso]

I'd say LeBron because he seems more of a team player, IMO.

[fgrep15]

Who will have a better second season?

Well this is what I think it will be like:

Lebron: 23.0 points, 5.6 rebounds, 5.9 assists, 42.7% FG, 31.1% 3PT

Carmelo: 25.1 points, 6.4 rebounds, 3.1 assists, 44.5% FG, 35.1% 3PT


I guess I could say, you decide