Overrated and Underrated players

[Arcane]

im gonna stir the pot with my selection

OVERRATED

Kobe
Malone
Iverson
Walker
Hill
Shaq (but if helps brings a championship to Miami then i'll let it slide)

UNDERRATED

Eddie Jones
Allen
Melo (for being overlooked for co rookie of the year)
thats all i can think of for now

[-BHZMAFIA-]

Well Bibby is a pretty good player, but people shouldn't underrate him because he isn't underrated. If he was anything he would be in the middle or overrated. I wouldn't make him an underrated type player IMO. I have to agree that he is a clutch player and is the best clutch player on the Kings because I have seen him make many clutch shots. I've also seen him light the nets up before, but he isn't that consistent to do it every game though.

[magius]

overrated:

paul pierce
chris webber
dirk nowitzki
karl malone
shareef
michael finley kinda
van horn
allan houston
marion super kinda
christie
rashard lewis
vince carter
jerry stackhouse

underrated:

tim duncan
andre miller
elton brand
dwayne wade
shaq
redd
marbury
eric snow
stoudamire
camby
ratliff
chandler
steve nash
mike bibby
battier
diaw maybe
dale davis
rick fox/horry
stephen jackson maybe maybe
tinsley super duper maybe
brevin knight kinda
yao ming
pippen
rodman
mutumbo

missed a bunch, left out some of the more obvious ones, some are questionable, ohe well. bye bye.

[Matt]

sorry Magius....i gotta say that Finley is underrated. Look at Dallas' record over the last 2 years when Finley scores 20+....it's something like 40+ wins and about 3 or 4 losses. He wasn't forcing anything in Dallas but now that Nash is gone i'll assum he'll take a bigger role on offence.

[-BHZMAFIA-]

overrated:

paul pierce
chris webber
dirk nowitzki
karl malone
shareef
michael finley kinda
van horn
allan houston
marion super kinda
christie
rashard lewis
vince carter
jerry stackhouse

underrated:

tim duncan
andre miller
elton brand
dwayne wade
shaq
redd
marbury
eric snow
stoudamire
camby
ratliff
chandler
steve nash
mike bibby
battier
diaw maybe
dale davis
rick fox/horry
stephen jackson maybe maybe
tinsley super duper maybe
brevin knight kinda
yao ming
pippen
rodman
mutumbo

missed a bunch, left out some of the more obvious ones, some are questionable, ohe well. bye bye.

christie is underrated..if he was overrated then u would hear stuff about christie this and christie that which i dont hear. rashard lewis is underrated as well. rick fox being underrated LMAO

[air gordon]

what's with the wishy washy "kinda", "super kinda" comments, magius? c'mon, take a stand

imo eddie jones used to be underrated back in his laker & hornet days then went to the overrated list once when he went to miami. now he bounced back with a solid season so that puts him in neither