Him or Him

well ima have to say Zack Randolf he has more weapons then Boozer



Carlos Arroyo or Troy Hudson

Arroyo, because he's starting and is a key factor on a team that's surpassed everyone's expectations. Hudson has barely played yet.

LeBron James or Carmelo Anthony

This will be a huge spam thread

to my surprise, its doing very good.

i'd say lebron. hometown hero, consistent, leadership, and atheletisism. although melo has a lot of that too, in college, his PG was the leader.

tim duncan or KG?

tim duncan. he's a true leader, who can bring his team to championship.
it's a hard one though.

pippen or kobe ?

Pippen in his prime I'm assuming, so I'm going to go with Pippen. He might have never scored 30ppg, but he was a better defender, rebounder, and passer, and he was a much higher percentage shooter.



Isiah Thomas prime or Jason Kidd

Isiah Thomas. He led the Pistons to 2 championships

Penny Hardaway Prime or Grant Hill Prime?

Grant Hill cuz he was a more of a all round player on the Pistons



Ray Allen(MIL) or Ray Allen (SEA)

Ray Allen Seattle, in Seattle Ray has taken more of a role as a playmaker and is showing that he is very competent at being a playmaker.

Andre Miller or Mike Bibby

Mike Bibby(I hate him though). He's a good passer and ball handler. Also a much better shooter than Miller.


Baron Davis or Steve Francis?

davis...the baron's a mvp candidate while francis is giving migraine's to jvg

mark madsen or brian cardinal?

Brian Cardinal, he has the hustle, he can score and is a very good shooter , Madsen just has hustle.


Jason Richardson or Quentin Richardson

'q' gets the edge. finding his niche in the brand and Maggette-o clips

jalen rose or jamal crawford?

'q' gets the edge. finding his niche in the brand and Maggette-o clips

jalen rose or jamal crawford?

Jalen Rose, cause he's more versatile than Crawford and way more consistent than Crawford (at least as a Raptor).

Dirk or Peja?

Peja this year Dirk Last year
Man that is a tough one though.
Overall I'd go with Peja cause it seems like he can nail every shot.
Both excellent shooters but Peja is a slightly better shooter and is really steppig up without Webber on the team. (Make it 3 years in a row at the 3 point shootout)

Mason or or J-Rich?

J-Rich has a better future but Mason's going to the playoffs, so i pick him.

David Robinson or Patrick Ewing

Admiral or Ewing

Your answer's up there Sliccat.

Better Dunker?

Carmelo Anthony OR Allen Iverson OR Andre Miller OR Darvin Ham

( )

Darvin Ham, by a mile.

Kurt Thomas or Kenny Thomas?

Kurt. He has more inside presence and can play the 4 and 5 spot. Kenny's got a better shot but Kurt's better down low and better at keeping the centers in check.

Gary Payton 95-96 or Jason Kidd 2002-2003

Admiral or Ewing

Your answer's up there Sliccat.

Oops, didn't see it

Kurt can do everything Kenny can, and he's tougher.

Allen Iverson or Steph

This will be a huge spam thread

to my surprise, its doing very good.

you got that right!

Answer... became MVP, brought Phillies to the Finals

Rip Hamilton or Ricky Davis

Rip Hamilton at least he aint a cancer


Kenyon Martin or Jamal Masburn

Jamal Mashburn because he is more consistent and score every night.

Jwill or Bibby

Bibby. More of a leader, more dependable and less erratic.

Pau Gasol or Kirilenko?