I agree, as long as he have the sliders the game will be alright. It's all about adding features or improving features, problems start when EA starts taking out some features: for example: chance to save during game, create a team option, and Clutch ratings. All this features were removed and people is still complaining about it, me too.
I want the game to be more realistic everyday, gameplay should be improved the most, graphics are and always will be a nice accesory, the main feature is the gameplay.
The game should more customisable each version, I wish NBA 06 will have more sliders and will add some tendencies ratings, I know it is bound to happen someday, but I guess it won't happen for NBA 06.
EA is still focusing too much on graphics and that bothers me somehow. However, competition ESPN crew included, are far behind even in terms of gameplay, I played ESPN's game in PS2 and I found it very dissapointing, I'd rather stay with my NBA Live 05 cos by editing some players and working on the sliders I got a decent simulation of a basketball game. ESPN was unable to do so.
Let's wait and see what EA brings on this year, high expectations are as bad as the low expectations of the main responsible of this thread.