I'm trying out The One on All-Star difficulty, and I'm finding that the CPU and myself make layups way too often. My 71 OVR stretch PF is nearly automatic by simply catching a pass in the paint and pressing shoot, even when contested. It's even worse for the CPU who can drive to the hoop at will and make almost every layup/dunk.
I've tried tweaking sliders, but I'm not sure it's having any effect in The One? I've tried Superstar difficulty, but jumpers become much more difficult, and it makes the CPU issue even worse.
Perhaps I'm used to 2K20's larger learning curve and shot stick where choosing the right type of layup/gather is critical. It seems Live handles that for you? Or maybe I've just gotten lucky in my first few games?