by koberulz on Sat Dec 28, 2013 3:48 am
Finally got around to watching Payback. Don't understand how Punk-Jericho is included in the MOTY conversation. I thought it was terrible. Punk was clearly out of shape, and seemed to blow up fairly early. If it was a work, it was done horribly. There was a lot of lying around by both guys for no reason, which made the pace horrendously slow, and not in a way that worked. **
The IC triple threat, particularly looking back now, could hardly have had three worse guys in it. I had no idea who the champion was even after his music started, as Barrett never managed to get a televised introduction, Axel is terrible, and Miz is just boring. The figure-four doesn't suit him in the slightest, and I can't understand why they thought to give him that gimmick. Perceptions around the three guys involved may have been different at the time, though, so it's a bit hard to analyse from that perspective now. Tremendous finish, which managed to get all four guys (including Heyman) over, so from that point of view it did its job. **½
Ugh, the Kaitlyn crying gimmick. Maybe there's a woman out there who could pull it off, but Kaitlyn isn't her. She makes way more sense as a tough asskicker. AJ was AJ, but it's a divas match, so it's tough to really care. **¼
Kane-Ambrose...was there. Honestly, I'd forgotten it happened until I was reading the results to compile this. It was pretty much there to serve the angle breaking up Team Hell No by giving Kane that shot and forcing Orton and Bryan to team. Did its job, in that it happened, but the PPV bit was actually entirely pointless, with everything this match was for playing out on TV. NR
Ziggler-Del Rio was just tremendous. Everyone did their job absolutely perfectly. Ziggler sold the concussion like a motherfucker, AJ looked so concerned for his safety I actually started believing what I was watching, and Del Rio did a tremendous job of beating the shit out of him while occasionally looking at the fans with an expression on his face that was clearly "what are you booing me for?" Terrible booking, and one does wonder how long Ziggler may have held the strap if it weren't for that concussion, but everyone involved went out there and put that match over. Essentially a glorified squash, though, so it rates lower than it perhaps should. ***½
Orton is an upgrade on Kane, particularly with the faster pace worked by the Shield and Daniel Bryan, and the other three had a history of fantastic matches, so I was expecting more from this. Crowd struggled to care early, coming down from Punk-Jericho, which hurt it a bit. Not the best Shield/Bryan contest, but far from bad. ***
I'm torn on the Three Stages of Hell. On the one hand, lumberjack matches are terrible ("we're heels! Let's beat up the face for no reason other than that we're heels!"), as are ambulance matches, so I'm tempted to go with zero stars, particularly given the use of the world's most blatant break-apart ambulance. Cena ripped off the light bar completely, and the lights kept flashing. Ryback going through the roof was just the icing on the cake-soft vehicle. The tables component was pretty much the match they did in Perth. The table spots were identical, at least. On the other hand, Cena diving to the outside deserves five stars. I'll split the difference. **½
So that said, my ratings for all the MOTY contenders I know of (minus Punk-Cena from Raw, which I haven't seen yet):
Punk-Taker: ***
Punk-Jericho: **
Zayn-Cesaro: ***¾
Punk-Brock: ****½
Cena-Bryan: ****½
Punk-Brock edges Cena-Bryan on audible spots.