by fgrep15 on Sun Aug 08, 2004 5:49 pm
First, saying Carter can't shoot is pretty baseless considering he shot 40+% from three point range in his 2nd and 3rd years, has a career 38.6 3PT%, and is one of the better mid-range shooters in the league.... but you clarified that you went overboard.
Saying he can't play defense holds the same conditions, he's a slightly above average defender, just not a good one unless he wants to be, but it's the fact that he doesn't play defense like he can regularly that really makes people get angry about his D.
A few things:
The comparison between Allen and Vince would have been scrutinized a while ago, but now is very legit. Ray Allen has just as good an all-round game, better handles, is a better shooter, but gets injured pretty fairly too. Carter is not far off in any of those categories, is younger, is more able to take over on both ends of the floor, and his numbers can't directly be compared to Allen's due to the systems they played in.
If we could get a deal Vince, Donyell Marshall, and Alvin Williams for Ray Allen, Vitaly Potapenko, and Radmonovic it would be nice. Or maybe Antonio Daniels instead of Potapenko.
If Ray Allen comes to Toronto, I would be concerned about defense at the SF spot with Jalen Rose there, Rose is weak and slow, and is a crappy defender anywhere he plays, but Vince could guard SF's, so it was fine. With Allen who isn't any better a defender than Carter (also about average), and Carter not playing lazy is better, we wouldn't have anyone to effectively guard the 3 because Allen would have a height and strength disadvantage, and he isn't aggressive enough on defense to effectively guard the 3.
I also feel he might "pull a Boozer" on us, and say he'll re-sign if we trade for him, and bail leaving Toronto with "cap space", and what has that ever done for us, our biggest signing ever that wasn't out own FA was Hakeem Olajuwon, and look what that brought to the team.
Lastly, Vince would finally be playing in a running offense style next year, and it would be nice to see how he fits in it in Toronto, rather than in Seattle. His numbers especially his assists (more shots taken with players who can make shots) and rebound numbers (Kevin O'neil didn't want players to go after offensive boards, which cuts about 1 rebound a game from Carter's numbers) should go up, and his scoring and FG% (more easy baskets through ball movment and transition) should face a decent increase too.
All in all, Carter playing is a system like Allen's will very likely put up better numbers, and he's younger, already making less, and is signed for a while.
Ray Allen might be asking for 6 years 100+ million as his new contract, and I wouldn't be willing to pay that for a 30 year old SG.
CP3 | Brand | Arenas | Calderon
Raptors | Wizards | Clippers