They are very similar... Redd is more of a 3 pt bomber while Rip has one of the best midrange games... I'd say Redd was more deserving... Rip will be an All-Star someday, too. Too bad his team wins more and he has better players to play with...
Redd is a decent slasher.. very good from outside, a better scorer
Rip has a better midrange game tho.. he is one of the best at the 12-20 footers, he is more of a shooter
Redd = scorer, Rip = shooter
scorer > shooter
Redd is main man for Bucks, Rip's got Billups to take the clutch ones, and Ben is most popular player on the team..