NBA_Fan_23 wrote:Yeah Joe Dumars sure was right in taking Dracula over Carmelo or Chris bosh..
people have go to understand that any other team in that situation would have take probably melo and then 3rd pick would have been Darko, Toronto was dissapointed that they got Bosh so no criticism should be put on Dumars, and if Bosh was on the pistons he wouldn't play as much but for sure he would play more than Darko b/c he's a fundementally sound and a smart player.
NBA_Fan_23 wrote:The way I see it, Detroit isn't really a contendor when they dont have a legitimate goto guy down the strecth.
In 2002, they lost to boston in the conference semi finals in 5 games becuase of their scoring
same again last year by this time to the nets and in 4 games.
they could have Chauncey seting things up
either going down low to Elden Campbell or Corliss Williamson or even Mehmet Okur
and then if things break down (like they have in the past for detroit) they can clear out and put the ball in the hands of Carmelo and let him break down his man one on one.
Thats really all detroit needs to make themselves into a contendor imo
but instead they took Darko who isnt going to help them for at least 2 or 3 more years. So you tell me if dumars is such a genius, considering they could be contendors and they couldve taken a much better player now in melo with the same (if not more) potential than Darko.
No one in the Eastern Conference is a contender...
They lost because they only had one scorer...Jerry Stackhouse, who was a low percentage shooter and thus, the Celtics clamped down on him...
Last year was different from the year before because they had multiple scoring options. Billups was the go-to-guy, while Rip was a consistant scorer and Tayshaun took advantage of the Sixers inability to guard him to be a scorer. Then, when Billups and Wallace were battered by injuries and the team fell apart aside from Rip (who continued to drop 20+ against the Nets) and they gave up in the last two games.
No, they couldn't. Billups is a scorer, not a guy who sets things up. He's going to be making himself the go-to-guy instead of setting up his teammates.
Campbell is done, out of the rotation, finished. Williamson still suffers from being 6-6 and unless Mehmo listens to Brown and stops standing outside and instead goes inside against guys who can't keep up with his quickness they'd be going inside to Darko and Zelly
Which would never happen, because teams would simply focus on and shut down the low percentage scorer like they did to Stackhouse.
That wouldn't make them a contender. It might ensure a top five Eastern finish, but adding Anthony to this team would not make it able to defeat any of the Western Four or Minnesota.
Darko has made bigger strides than anyone I have seen this season
He's finally confident enough on the offensive end to use his passing skills, he's posting his man a lot better and making smarter moves to the hoop. He's playing within the team and in the sets leagues better than he was. Defensively he is no longer playing a zone and losing his man, he's staying with him and holding his ground. His defensive anticipation has also improved, he's timing his blocks a lot better than before. If he keeps this up, he'll probably make a bigger playoff impact than Prince did, if the Pistons can make the playoffs. I also expect Darko to play a lot more minutes, Campbell is out of the rotation and Okur won't stop being stupid. If Brown would play Darko alongside Zelly or maybe even Okur coming off the bench it would work wonders and might prove to Brown that Corliss is not best used at power forward.
if they drafted Anthony they would be favourites to win the east, and with their defense and scoring options I could see them at least challenging for the NBA title. Look at Carmelo is doing in denver with less help on the offensive end, and alot less help defensively
are you going to tell me that Darko is the better option for right now?
This Piston team made the conference finals last year, its not like they are rebuilding so why take such a gamble on a project player such as darko who will take along time to be ready.
Hell, the more I think about it, the more I realise just how bad Detroit fucked up. They could've traded prince to portland for Randolph
Lol yeah, he got a whole 3 points, what huge strides this young man is makingp
as for now, Carmelo wouldve helped the Pistons a whole lot more than what Darko has done so far, and that cannot be disputed.
I don't know how much Tayshaun averaged in the series against Philadelphia, but his mismatch created problems for McKie and Buckner that required doubles that opened the floor. Billups dropped off from the Orlando series to the Philadelphia series because of the injury, Philadelphia would not have been able to hold on to six games had Billups been healthy like he was against Orlando. The Nets won because not only could Detroit not score but because they stopped playing defense.
No, Billups cannot play a role similar to Marbury. He is not the talent Marbury is. Billups is seeing the floor as first, how he will score not as how the Pistons will score, if he changes that he might be able to do it, but I doubt he will since that's how he's played his entire life.
You may have said go down low to Mehmo, but he doesn't go down low, he stands at the top of the key and then either tries to drive or shoot from the outside. Darko can go in the post and that where he is his best offensively.
The 2002 Pistons had Williamson off the bench as well. And you added this qualifier "if things break down (like they have in the past for detroit)", which means the rest of the team cannot score, so that would imply the remainder of the Pistons scorers were cold.
You are completely and utterly wrong. Carmelo Anthony in Denver has more offensive assistance (1) that he would receive in Detroit, Bzdelik has implimented a high octane scoring style (2) and Anthony is flanked with Lenard, Barry, Miller, Boykins and White who are playing simply gangbusters on the offensive end. Detroit's defense is better than Denver's as much as Denver's offense is better than Detroit's so the teams are actually dead even. With Anthony the offense would stay the same and the defense would drop. Anthony can't play defense at anywhere near Fowlkes or Prince's level and his offense is a wash because of the number of attempts he needs to get his points.
Who said anything about right now...I said three years.
How exactly were they supposed to do that...Portland wasn't turning over Randolph.
It's easy to make jokes when you don't ever see him play.
Yes, it can. As I already explained, Carmelo would hurt the Pistons on both ends of the floor due to how they play. Darko doesn't hurt them on either end, yes, because he doesn't play.
lol, Barry, lenord, Miller, White and Boykins are better than Hamilton, Billups, Okur, Atkins, Sura, Okur, Zelly etc etc? Please,.. Don't look at the system, look at the players and you tell me which team has the better offensive talent.... lol John Barry, Rodney White, Earl Boykins, Voshorn Lenord... these players are a joke. Andre Miller is good, but even then I'd rather Chauncey when it comes to putting the ball in the hole.
3 years, now thats a plan for an unproven overseas player who is what? 17 years old? So he will be 20.. and even then he probably wont be a force.
This Detroit team made the conference finals and (according to you) a big reason as to why they lost was becuase of injuries, so... why are they rebuilding?
How do you know they wouldnt have swapped Prince for Randolph? Portland had lost Pippen, they wouldnt have known about Rasheeds up coming bad season that he is having now. I think portland wouldve done this deal, and maybe a first rounder from detroit or another team couldve been added to get portland more interested.
I saw him miss that dunk in cleveland,
Thats just stupid. Carmelo "would hurt them on offense".. right.
You can "lol" all you want, but you're denying reality if think Denver's offense and those players are not besting the Pistons this year.
He's not supposed to be an end-all-be-all force, he's supposed to be the piece that pushes the Pistons over the edge when they actually have a realistic shot.
So you admit you have no basis to analyze Darko's development on the court.
Detroit already plays at a near snails pace (and their offense for the first time in two years has fallen out of the top 13 in the league). In order to get all the shots he needs to put up those numbers at his low FG% Carmelo would need to steal a third of the shots Chauncey and Rip get or taking opportunies from every player. Provided he doesn't settle to be the third or fourth option on offense (making him less productive than Prince). He would also create a gaping hole on the wing on defense. Tayshaun Prince and Tremaine Fowlkes are two legit defensive stoppers who can lock up the wing (and in Tayshauns case even defend at PF and PG), Carmelo is not even a speed bump, he is the grooves on the side of the road that wake you up when fall asleep and drift.
Because they are just two years after they won only 32 games, they have only two players from that team, over half the team has never played here. That's just like a rebuilding club like Denver and Cleveland.
Is Carmelo Anthony a very good player? Yes. Is he better than Darko now? Yes. Will he always be better than Darko? Maybe. Is he better for the Pistons now or in three years? No
if you you honestly think that Lenord, Andre Miller, Jon Barry and Rodney White are superior offenisve players than Ripchard, Chauncey Billups, Mehmet Okur and Corliss Williamson then of course I'm going to laugh at you.
Numbers can be decieving, and Denvers system is run and gun which means better and more shots. If you don't believe that, then what does it come down to? Carmelo Anthony joining the team? But wait.. I thought he is detrimental on the offensive end (or is that just detroit, who can't score anyway).
So why would they have added guys like Bobby Sura and Elden Campbell now? These players will be shells of their prime in 3 or 4 years..
and if they were just rebuilding becuase they suck so terribly now wouldn't it make more sense to just tank games and get better draft picks?
This was the logic you used to say Jordan was selfish to come back to the wizards, becuase he was "hurting" them becuase they were more competitive and not getting the higher lottery picks...
And when you think about the Zach Randolph trade scenario, considering it wouldve been in the off season i think the Blazers would've done it. They could've been talked into it simply by showing how well Tayshuan did against Tmac in the playoffs and "all the matchup problems he caused philly" and then add to that the fact that Zach and Rasheed play the same position. This is the same portland organisation that traded Jermaine O'neal for Dale Davis, so I have no doubt that they could've been talked into a deal.
Ive seen him play twice and he reminds me of Shawn Bradley as a rookie...
Carmelo showed on the college level he can play effectively in half court on offense (and against a zone in that half court too, i might add)
and Carmelo was to be effective in detroit, the plan was to get Chauncey to share the ball and be somewhat of a playmaker
Detroit (still) needs a player to score down the stretch of a close game, a guy that can create his own shot
Melo would make them better right now becuase he is a legitimate scoring threat down the stretch of a game, and he isnt bad on defense. You seem to love stats (like denvers ppg) so heres some:
Tayshaun Prince 0.74 bpg, 0.85 spg and 5.1 rpg
Carmelo Anthony 0.85 bpg, 1.26 spg and 5.4rpg
So according to stats, Carmelo is the superior defensive player and a better rebounder and a better scorer. But nah, he wont help the Pistons now will he...
scubilete wrote:If at least Darko was getting the opportunity of playing, but how can you think he's a that bad if he's not getting playing time? I'd easily say this Knicks rookie is a shitty as well (Sweetney) but he's not getting playing time so nobody can judge him for not getting great numbers, and the fact that a particular team doesn't use a player is for different reasons.
Obviously Prince is an example, nobody knew he could play until we saw him in the playoffs. At least I would say, if he wouldn't have played that great, many would believe he was going to be cut (if we followed his season numbers) or at least he was going to try harder than anyone to make the team this year. But no, he played great and surprise the world showing that not getting playing time during the season didn't affect his game. (After all, he was a first rounder)
The case is the Pistons DID NOT WANT CARMELO, it's not that they made a mistake, they took whoever they wanted, Milicic is the player they wanted, and they'll wait for him to develop, most of you are still waiting for Kwame who everyone knows how bad he sucks, what's so bad to wait a bit for Milicic who at least is not getting the opportunities Kwame & LeBron got when they came to the league?...
Points Per 48 Minutes:
C. Anthony - 25.3
A. Miller - 22.7
V. Lenard - 24.5
E. Boykins - 24.0
J. Barry - 15.3
R. White - 28.0
C. Billups - 24.3
R. Hamilton - 24.5
M. Okur - 19.8
C. Williamson - 20.0
Run-and-gun doesn't mean better shots, it means more shots. So, of course, we account for that. Thus, we took a look at how many points each team scored per 100 posessions which was 100.9 for Denver and 97.8 for Detroit. Detroit cannot score this year, but the last two years they have been 10th and 13th in the league in scoring.
Because they aren't going to be around in 3 or 4 years...Sura was acquired because his contract expires after this season...Campbell expires in two if they keep him that long
No.
No? Never said that? Jordan hurt the Wizards by dealing and signing away their cap space with poor players and his playing did nothing to help the team because he was so hell bent on winning then they were playing him and guys like Charles Oakley and Byron Russell who had no business being there.
Sigh...must you continue and live in MatthewWorld...
Portland would have never traded Zach Randolph (who averaged 20 points and 11 rebounds during the season when he got 30+ minutes...who tore it up at a simliar pace and led the team back against the Mavericks...who they decided to make the centerpiece of the team) for Tayshaun Prince. Prince stopping McGrady and abusing Philadelphia's 6-4 and 6-5 Small Forwards would not be more enticing than Randolph's playing like an All-Star.
I've seen him play every time.
That's college. He also shot 60 points higher in College.
What plan? There was no plan to even take Carmelo after they saw Darko's workout.
Billups seemed to step into that role in the playoffs last year.
I'm surprised. You think blocks, steals and rebounds determine how good a player is defensively. As everyone knows, Tayshaun Prince and Tremaine Fowlkes are stoppers. Carmelo Anthony is grooves. You can keep throwing out rebounds, blocks and steals, but you'll just look foolish since everyone knows that says little about a players ability to play defense. Bruce Bowen gets 1.52 steals per 48, but everyone knows he's the best wing/perimeter defender in the league.
Carmelo Anthony with Tayshaun Prince's attempts: 12.7 points per 48 (vs. 14.2)
Tayshaun Prince with Carmelo Anthony's attempts: 27.8 points per 48 (vs. 25.3)
Carmelo Anthony with average of the two's attempts: 19.0
Tayshaun Prince with average of the two's attempts: 21.0
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests