Kings vs. Suns: bad call on Miller shot

Just to get it clear for all of you, it wasn't a clean block. What I mentioned about the 'imaginary cillinder' is true.

In the NBA they have this rule and the one where you can't touch it after it has reached his highest point.
In Europe we don't have the first rule with the cillinder above the rim, I even read an article from players on the US olympic team, they had to get used to the rule difference.

only the ball wasn't IN the imaginary cylinder.

You couldn't tell from any of the angles IMO.

Shit, cklitsie, did you really needed to quote that many times??



I spelt your name right

only the ball wasn't IN the imaginary cylinder.

Watch it on nba.com.
I love being right.

or from this link
http://misterkobe.chez.tiscali.fr//e28e ... 209b01b.rm



It was a goal tend imo, that and a off the ball foul from marion on webber.

only the ball wasn't IN the imaginary cylinder.

Exactly. The ball has to be right above the cylinder, not PARTIALLY IN the cylinder. If it is not in the cylinder then the only way it could be goaltending is if the ball was coming down which it wasnt. Also, am I the only one seeing Webber push Marion to the ground yet people are complaining about marion fouling webber?

The ball was over the rim. When you move the ball when it's over the rim, no matter how little, it's a goaltend.

Please, just watch it on nba.com/video
It''s clearly above the cillinder goaltend

Please, just watch it on nba.com/video
It''s clearly above the cillinder goaltend

its definitely ABOVE, but not IN the cylinder. thats why there's no goaltending on that play.

close call though

I didn't see the game but my friends told me Webber got fined cause he threw the ball at someone...I laughed my a$$ off!!
Is it true??

if Miller wasn't such a pussy he would of dunked it and this debate wouldn't happen.

please read point B before u guys make your judgement
http://www.nba.com/analysis/rules_11.html?nav=ArticleList

Same thing happened vs. Dallas last night, only the call was even more obvious.

Ya on Mobley's shot there was a goaltend.

Yo, all of u look at this:

http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/recap?gameId=250211023

Kings got screwed this week.

The way Miller got pissed after Amare blocked his shot was odd. He fucking threw off his headband, and his face went super red.

Like this:

Ya they got screwed twice.

Ya they got screwed twice.

two games that werent called as goaltends for kings they should get a new ref kings should have won,the ref is like 90 he is blind

It's really pathetic. Two games of three.

And none of them should have been fined or suspended. That's how stiupid the NBA can be.

And if they had Miller vs. Seattle, maybe they wouldn't have lost that game either.

They should get screwed every single game, stupid queens
It was a clean block by Amare btw.

They should get screwed every single game, stupid queens
It was a clean block by Amare btw.

hey Donyell do u really know the difference between a block and a goaltend , i dont think u do,you better check out the difference right now

Ya the Amare one maybe, but the Dallas one really pisses me off that was a sure goaltend!


http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/recap?gameId=250211023

no they were both goaltends and if u dont notice that, then ur as blind as the ref in the game

I watched it a couple of times and it looks like a goaltend to me...

i know thats wat i have been telling donyell but no he says it was a clear block, tell me how could the ref be so dumb?or was he just taking there side because he liked them better