I've got the 88 allstar game from Pontel as well and MJ's dunks while being fairly simple just have something about them that is impressive. The way he kicks his legs and moves his arms around make the dunks seem more amazing then they actually are imo.
It's the same with Dr and Nique. They were able to make simple dunks look impressive - even when they did the same sort of dunks a few times in a single dunk contest. MJ double-pumped when he leapt from the free throw line - the way he leapt, it didn't matter that his foot was not completely behind the line.
Dr J put his foot over the line too, but he dunked it emphatically. He didn't just hold the ball over his head and get it over the rim - he slammed it home.
The extension that Nique showed when he performed his famous windmill dunks was awesome, as was the power as the ball was slammed through the hoop.
Sure, their names and reputation might have something to do with us holding their dunks in such high esteem. But they all put that "flavour" in their dunks that made them special, something that can't be imitated by just any athletic player; another reason why getting rid of the wheel was a good move.

