In NBA Inside Stuff Mag they compare Mello and Peja.

I just bought the latest NBA Inside stuff mag and they got Peja vs Carmello Head 2 Head then what really got me angry they reckoned Peja was the better all round player.

I doubt that very much that Peja is the better player...

What do you guys think?

That's interesting; I thought to be a good all around player, you had to actually be an all around player. I don't consider Melo to be a fantastic defender but I'd easily call him the better all around player compared to Peja, who is a great shooter but a competent defender at best.