Manu Ginobli or Richard Hamilton?

[Matt]

both guys fit in very well with their teams

[Ataraxia]

When Reg is gone, Rip should be the best without the ball... he can run and he can shoot. I'd pick Rip over Manu though....

Ray Allen?

For some strange reason I never liked Manu even though I support the Spurs....Ive always been hoping he gets traded....I dunno maybe the fact that he is terribly inconsistant....even this season he dropped off after yet another good start...but hes done well against the Nuggets...but he'll get shut down by Ray in round 2.

But that being said Manu is prolly better than Rip.

[MaD_hAND1e]

Rip is a poor man's Reggie Miller.

[air gordon]

iverson moves just as well w/o the ball as miller and rip does. you don't get to see as much since he took over pg duties this year

[galvatron3000]

Here's the thing, Manu does more than Rip and is a more explosive player. Manu has a nie mid range jumper though he doesn't take as many as Rip simply because on their respective teams it is not necessary for Manu too as much and he goes to the line alot. Rip is not a deep ball threat but a much better mid-range shooting threat(because of his lack of consistent 3pt range) Manu is probably a better defender, he's good off the ball too(maybe not quite as good as Rip hard to say cause that's Rip game not on the ball) Manu is much moe versatile but all being siad you can't go wrong with either but I'd take the guy who gets everyone in foul trouble(ask Shaq), who's fearless and who is just so unpredictable. I'd take Manu. I'd take Rip as a back up though.

Oh yeah Manu got a ring in 2003 so I guess you'll be taking Manu now.

[Strike Freedom]

Rip got a ring in 2004..?

but i still say Manu is better..
cuz he's been doing alot of things.. oncourt to win..
Detroit doesn't need RIP to win..
but Spurs need Manu.. to win..
and of course Duncan as well..

[Null17]

what about parker?

and manu was part of the last spurs championship...so they both have rings although both have a good chance of getting one more this season