RJ or VC: Who'd you trade?

Who would you trade if you had to trade one of the two swing-men?

i said vince, not too sure why, maybe u just dont like him

RJ 4 sho...VC is a superstar man...he's been doin it for yrs...why trade away a player that can contribute so much?

On NJ RJ contributes more tahn Carter does.

Jefferson is younger hence he should be traded. Carter is good but he's old.

On NJ RJ contributes more tahn Carter does.

Carter actually scores 2 more points a game.

There numbers are actually similar. RJ gets +3 in rebounds, but VC outdoes RJ in FT%.

VC's 3 years older.

Jefferson is younger hence he should be traded. Carter is good but he's old.

How does that make sense? You'd want to keep the younger guy.

this is a tough one. Carter is a better shooter, but they have a similar game. Carter is injury prone, though after being traded, he hasn't missed a lot of games. I guess this also depends on who they get back. ........ hmmm i think i 'll go for Carter just cause he's old. Not a great reason, but i can't think any other.

Keep them both and trade Scott Padgett

Keep them both and trade Scott Padgett

Padgett had a monster game today.

I guess this also depends on who they get back. ........

that makes alot of sence

if your going to do a trade, market them both and see the deal you like most, however it would probably piss off the guy who isnt traded as they wont feel as wanted to the team anymore.

I'd trade away Vince. Jefferson can really put up numbers other than scoring.

easy....Carter

you never have to question Jefferson. He didn't tank the season like Carter did in Toronto. He plays better D than Carter too and pulls down rebounds in traffic, not to mention he doesn't get injured like Carter either.

Well, he did miss most of last season.

Trade Carter. RJ was doing well before VC came to Jersey and RJ is half the whiny bitch that VC is.

trade jefferson for sure carter is a lot better

On a business perspective, I'd trade RJ. VC's more marketable. Any casual NBA fan knows who he is. He'd sell more merchandise. etc

But if I'm going to think about the team's future, I'd trade VC away. RJ is younger. and trading VC IMO would have more value and a chance to get a good younger guy with a lot of potential to develop

VC. He is more injury prone, more of a drama queen and doesn't play D. Jefferson is still improving (a lot) and could very well end up being of the better/best all-around players in the L. He'll never sell as many jerseys as Half Man Half Injury, but he'll certainly become a superstar in his own right. And for that to come, he needs more ball and that means someone needs to go and - by my opinion - that's Carter. They could get a decent big man in return.

Jefferson. He has a better attitude, more talent, and a better age.

I'd trade away Vince. Jefferson can really put up numbers other than scoring.

As if a Canadian would say otherwise...

there's no team chemistry this season in NJ....last year we thought they would have a breakout season with RJ back, but nothing happens....this season I don't recognize this old good Vince Carter of the past, about 4 or 3 seasons behind...remember at this time when he was in the top ten every week (for crunch time winning baskets most of the time).
I'd trade for Vince

Get rid of RJ.
-Vince puts arses in the seats.
-He is a superstar player, RJ is not.
-Hes an allstar.
-I think VC is more consistent, and is capable of doing more damage than RJ.

Jefferson is younger and a better defender, plus Carter has pretty much gotten away from what he did last season.

I'd trade Carter.

Jefferson is younger hence he should be traded. Carter is good but he's old.

How does that make sense? You'd want to keep the younger guy.

Bah my bad...I wasn't thinking properly.

Carter and Jefferson both have amazing talent. I just like Vince a lot better, so I'd trade Jefferson, but that's just me.

anyone with any bball IQ would trade Carter over RJ.