Alright - I've been playing this game with my boys since Live '98. We always play with 5 guys, and play an entire team against the CPU.
Some things have been removed from the game that make no sense:
The player indicator - You used to be able to turn on the position indicator on every player on the court. This was extremely useful when trying to play man-to-man defense. This feature was removed-why?
User stats and profiles - This one really ticked me off. We used to be able to track our own stats as users. This was an endless source of enjoyment as we compared stats with each other. This feature was removed-why?
I really don't care about new modes and new animations, just put these simple things back in the game (it would be about 15 lines of code), and we can all enjoy this game again.