did you place the legend avery johnson player in ur game? if u did then thats what must be causing this... both of them use avjohns files so the computer might be confusing it with d player avery johnson... my suggestion would be changing avery johnson player files name... if u didn't place the legend avery in game though.. then u must have screwed something up on your dbf files...
the files you wil edit: avjohns.fsh, avjhons.ebo, and his portrait file...
change it to something unique so that the computer wont be confused on the file to choose... for example u can change it to... aejohns.fsh, aejohns.ebo... and whatever u renamed it with... change the playerpkg also in the player.dbf files to match it... again, using my example... his playerpkg would now be AEJOHNS... ope dis helps...