- Do you think a lot of pictures is important?
No. A couple here & there are good. Pictures are supplementary to the dynasty IMHO, not the main core of it. I'd prefer someone to take a bit of effort into presenting something quality with maybe one or two pics than just posting 15 pics from a game, as I tend not to waste my time checking out these dynasties. I guess I could understand if you're playing for the title, but otherwise, not really.
- Do you like long (Long as in my type of long that i had in my old dynasty Here)/short recaps (shorter than my old dynasty)?
Shorter recaps.
- Do you think a story behind it is important?
No, not if you're talking a story like in your dynasty. I think the main thing a dynasty needs is continuity & some sort of features, mini stories or plot lines. Like "That Guy" subplots. Not major stories, just sub-stories that supplement the dynasty.
- Replies in your thread is a good indicator of the people who follow it?
A combination of views & posts. High view to post ratios can either mean a lot of people follow the dynasty or you just don't update it much. If you're updating everyday, you're not going to get a 30 view to 1 post ratio. Whereas if you're updating twice a week, then 30 views per post is achievable. I run on a broad guideline that 10-15 views per post in an established dynasty as a sign that the dynasty is pretty successful.
- Does realism play a big part in dynasty?
Yes. Realistic stats, give or take. Real crap teams not winning the championship or making the playoffs in their first year. Not trading more than a couple of players in first season. That's just me though, & a couple of others.
- Does having NLSC players matter a lot?
Not a lot though. I've learnt that having NLSC players is mostly to add sub-plots to dynasties & shouldn't really be the core goal of the majority of dynasties (NLSC dynasties excluded). The main reason I had them was because I wanted to put myself in the game to live my life dream of playing in the NBA. It turns out a few other people wanted to be in as well. So not really necessary. I'd actually prefer to see the next Guy Dumars or Moses Chara than the next Makis Hassakis to tell you the truth
