shinron15 wrote:Compared to each? From what I've played with two of them (and seeing gameplay of Thomas), here's how I can break it down:
Payton vs Magic: Payton is faster and has better defensive skills, while Magic has better playmaking, and post skills, which creates mismatches for most guards in the game. If you're focusing on defense, I'd start Gary over Magic, but if you want a guard with a solid post-game, Magic's your man.
Penny vs Magic: Hardaway is good at finishing, however he cannot dunk, but he does have the best dribbling in the game. Magic has great dribbling, as well as the ability to dunk on a Fast Break transition. Dunking can make a difference to players at times (look at pre-patch Pippen compared to now; he plays much better now that he can dunk)
Thomas vs Magic: Thomas is faster, and has a good defensive rating (90), but compare his stats to Payton's, and Payton is the better option there. Magic somehow has a higher three point rating than Thomas. Plus with Magic's ability to basically be able to play any position on the offensive end, he's more useful than Thomas in that aspect.
Magic is a free card to get, so that's a plus, but you need to complete all the League Heroes challenges, have Hero Giannis and Davis, as well as three Slasher Playstyle players (legends also count) on your active lineup, and win the ten games to unlock him. Hope this helps
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests