by Andrew on Sun Dec 11, 2016 6:55 pm
It's interesting to see some of the reactions to Westbrook's stats among fans and sportswriters alike, especially compared to the historic numbers the Warriors were posting last season. Whereas anything less than glowing praise and unquestioning acceptance of the Warriors as The Undisputed Greatest Team of All-Time was met with cries of "hater!", or insistence that any criticism of the team was purely fuelled by nostalgia and bitterness, with Westbrook it seems to be the other way around. It's more fashionable and acceptable to downplay his accomplishments in favour of holding Oscar Robertson's accomplishment in higher regard, because Westbrook is just "chasing stats", and/or "hurting the team".
In other words, last year it was "accept that history is being made, and that the old isn't always better just because it's old", which to be fair, does have merit. However, it's a bit hypocritical when this year, it's "the numbers aren't as special as the old mark, because it's forced and manufactured, whereas the original record was a true accomplishment". It's kind of like the Warriors fans who argued that the Cavs couldn't blame the 2015 Finals loss on being without key players, but then tried to make the same excuse about the 3-1 collapse in 2016.
Honestly, I think much of it has to do with the fact that Westbrook plays for the Oklahoma City Thunder. The Thunder seem to be a popular team to dislike because of what happened in Seattle, even though that has nothing to do with the players and coaching staff, and it happened almost a decade ago. Once again, it's also rather hypocritical that people are told to get over LeBron leaving Cleveland in 2010 (which I'd say most Cavs fans certainly have by now) or Durant leaving the Thunder this past offseason, but anyone who still hates the Thunder and delights in their shortcomings is conversely displaying righteous outrage. You don't get to tell other people to get over things, while holding onto your own grudges. Well, you can - freedom of speech and all that - but you're definitely being a massive hypocrite in the process.
Anyway, all that aside...
I'm all in favour of letting the dust settle on records and accomplishments before putting them in historical perspective, but what Westbrook has done so far can certainly be called remarkable. Remember that a lot of people were claiming that LeBron would be the first player to average a triple-double in the modern era when he went to the Heat. I remember saying at the time it was unlikely as the opportunities to get those extra assists or rebounds would be harder to come by with two other stars on the team, since they'd be accounting for some of those stats as well. That Westbrook is posting these numbers in the wake of Durant's departure kind of reinforces that. Without another star posting big numbers, there are more opportunities to have big games, and in some cases, pad stats a little.
As far as him chasing stats...well, I think it's fair to say a lot of stars have done that over the years. Wilt did it when he led the league in assists, chiding teammates for "wasting" passes and being adamant that every assist was properly accounted for. MJ did the same in 1989 when he was getting all those triple-doubles, and he certainly went after the scoring championship year after year. Since it's The Big O's record we're talking about, he was also a pretty big jerk to his teammates when he felt they wasted an opportunity to get him an assist. To single any star out for supposedly chasing stats is a little unfair.
You could possibly make more of an argument about his one-man show being detrimental to the team, but it would seem his overall performance in the clutch doesn't gel with that thought. Additionally, with Durant and Ibaka gone, the team has much less proven talent, and he's far and away the only superstar on the roster. It's not a recipe for success in the long term, as Oscar Robertson's career with the Royals arguably demonstrates (the dominance of Russell's Celtics aside). But right now, it's what they have to work with: let Westbrook go nuts, and ride that until they can start putting a better team around him. He's undoubtedly putting on a show and doing something historically significant, too.