;-)

[seanbarkley]

Love that Melo!

Let's see if you can release ur Kevin Love soon man, I've been waiting for it!

[johnwest1985]

Like it !! Hope his ingame face is nice and chubby like the real one



i like his chick

[RR]

Amarowade,

The details are great when you see them from the front side, but if you look at their profile, especially in motion and in game they look flat and a bit unrealistic. All your cyberfaces have about the same size of nose and lips, as far as how much they protrude from the face when looking at them from a profile.

Again, this criticism is only meant to make your already great work even better. Thank you and keep up the amazing effort.

With all due respect for Amaro, I agree.

In this Carmelo preview, for example, it seems this great detailed face will come tiny, giving him a disproportional huge body....

[AmaroWaade]

Amarowade,

He looks great in the pictures. If I may so humbly do some criticism on your faces, albeit with a constructive intent.

When it comes to detail and textures, your faces are among the best if not the best. However I think that the headshapes have room for improvement. This is why I think most of your faces look amazing in screenshots but in-game the effect is not the same. Point of reference for this observation is your Paul George and your Paul Pierce cyberfaces.

The details are great when you see them from the front side, but if you look at their profile, especially in motion and in game they look flat and a bit unrealistic. All your cyberfaces have about the same size of nose and lips, as far as how much they protrude from the face when looking at them from a profile.

That's why for example your Paul George has much more detail than Kidow's Paul George, but Kidow's PG's nose and mouth look more real, because they somehow go outside of the face a bit.

Again, this criticism is only meant to make your already great work even better. Thank you and keep up the amazing effort.

Yes, but what does that have to do with Carmelo Anthony? I do not force anyone to download my cyberface. if you find them wrong you can not download them. I have already said I cge Paul George did not convince me. Kevin Love as I have not released. headshape many other users have used my last year. I honestly do not understand this then your very critical. it will mean that I will do as the Chinese. will release only to those who want it. ended the free sharing

[stielar]

Amarowade,

He looks great in the pictures. If I may so humbly do some criticism on your faces, albeit with a constructive intent.

When it comes to detail and textures, your faces are among the best if not the best. However I think that the headshapes have room for improvement. This is why I think most of your faces look amazing in screenshots but in-game the effect is not the same. Point of reference for this observation is your Paul George and your Paul Pierce cyberfaces.

The details are great when you see them from the front side, but if you look at their profile, especially in motion and in game they look flat and a bit unrealistic. All your cyberfaces have about the same size of nose and lips, as far as how much they protrude from the face when looking at them from a profile.

That's why for example your Paul George has much more detail than Kidow's Paul George, but Kidow's PG's nose and mouth look more real, because they somehow go outside of the face a bit.

Again, this criticism is only meant to make your already great work even better. Thank you and keep up the amazing effort.

Yes, but what does that have to do with Carmelo Anthony? I do not force anyone to download my cyberface. if you find them wrong you can not download them. I have already said I cge Paul George did not convince me. Kevin Love as I have not released. headshape many other users have used my last year. I honestly do not understand this then your very critical. it will mean that I will do as the Chinese. will release only to those who want it. ended the free sharing

Amarowade,

I think my post was amiable in every way and for no reason do I wish to critisize you or to say anything bad about your work. I hope you do understand that I thoroughly enjoy your cyberfaces and the work you have done so far. I am just saying my opinion how your great work could be even greater, as a friend would do if you showed him something and asked him what he thinks could be done to get it better.

Again, I apologize if my opinion came through the wrong way, maybe it's because neither me nor you are native English speakers, but I assure you that I only mean well.

[BigTicket]

I follow his work for some time, and the truth is that this year is much better.
From my point of view.
Thanks for the CF and waiting for the great Kevin Love CF.
Peace and no hard feelings.

[RJim]

did you released your melo already privately? If yes, it would be an honor for me to have it

[J.Davey]

Great!

"you can look but you can't touch" policy

[Maverick]

Yes, but what does that have to do with Carmelo Anthony? I do not force anyone to download my cyberface. if you find them wrong you can not download them. I have already said I cge Paul George did not convince me. Kevin Love as I have not released. headshape many other users have used my last year. I honestly do not understand this then your very critical. it will mean that I will do as the Chinese. will release only to those who want it. ended the free sharing

Amaro, that is just one man's opinion out of a thousands including me who thinks "we couldn't ask for more", know what I mean? So please don't stop the mass sharing.

[Brent72]

I really need a proper Melo CF for my game so I hope you release this for us, Amaro.

[stielar]

Yes, but what does that have to do with Carmelo Anthony? I do not force anyone to download my cyberface. if you find them wrong you can not download them. I have already said I cge Paul George did not convince me. Kevin Love as I have not released. headshape many other users have used my last year. I honestly do not understand this then your very critical. it will mean that I will do as the Chinese. will release only to those who want it. ended the free sharing

Amaro, that is just one man's opinion out of a thousands including me who thinks "we couldn't ask for more", know what I mean? So please don't stop the mass sharing.

Dmavs, I think the problem is that he misinterpreted my opinion. Anyone who reads my posts carefully will understand that I actually admire his work, and I am using many cyberfaces made by him. I only think that some of his faces' great aspects (attention to detail, amazing textures etc) could be better highlighted in a three dimensional spectrum.

[Maverick]

Yah! I guess he's not open to change how he believes how to create them and I think the comparison destroys it. Not all people likes their works to be compared to others works. Let's give it some time. He'll be back.







I hope!

[S_Brat]

WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Amarowade you never fail to impress... great work on melo

[DionWaiters]

Amarowade,

He looks great in the pictures. If I may so humbly do some criticism on your faces, albeit with a constructive intent.

When it comes to detail and textures, your faces are among the best if not the best. However I think that the headshapes have room for improvement. This is why I think most of your faces look amazing in screenshots but in-game the effect is not the same. Point of reference for this observation is your Paul George and your Paul Pierce cyberfaces.

The details are great when you see them from the front side, but if you look at their profile, especially in motion and in game they look flat and a bit unrealistic. All your cyberfaces have about the same size of nose and lips, as far as how much they protrude from the face when looking at them from a profile.

That's why for example your Paul George has much more detail than Kidow's Paul George, but Kidow's PG's nose and mouth look more real, because they somehow go outside of the face a bit.

Again, this criticism is only meant to make your already great work even better. Thank you and keep up the amazing effort.

Of all the times you could have written this post in here, you chose to do it after he posted previews to arguably the best Carmelo Anthony CF ever?!? What the hell is wrong with you man?

[ecwrulz91]

I hope you release that Carmelo Anthony good sir

[J.Davey]

Of all the times you could have written this post in here, you chose to do it after he posted previews to arguably the best Carmelo Anthony CF ever?!? What the hell is wrong with you man?

LOL, you're absolutely right!

[stielar]

Of all the times you could have written this post in here, you chose to do it after he posted previews to arguably the best Carmelo Anthony CF ever?!? What the hell is wrong with you man?

LOL, you're absolutely right!

This is getting tiresome... I like to give my honest opinion about everything. Bearing that in mind, I am very careful with the wording so that I don't come out as disrespectful. For crying out loud, check my Stielar's Cut edition and see how many of Amarowade's faces I've chosen as the best for certain players.

Regarding Paul George and the comparison I made with Kidow's Paul George...once again, check out Stielar's Cut. I chose Amarowade's Paul George because he was more detailed. But certain aspects of Kidow's could have been useful on Amarowade's face, and vice versa. I think both modders are excellent and I'm grateful that people like them share their work with us.

As far as why I posted this now is concerned...it's because I think previews are shown to people so that those interested can express their opinion and help the modder fine-tune some details before the final release. This is common practice in other game modding forums. If in here the rule is only worship the preview or shut up, let me know.

I'm sure all this is just some misunderstanding of my post. However if Amarowade has understood completely my tone and my intent, and is still angry with my criticism, I promise not to write ever again in his thread.

[Brent72]

So, get this. I PM'ed AmaroWaade telling him I thought his Carmelo CF was awesome and that if he didn't release it publicly I hoped he would still share it with those who requested it privately. He sent me back a message saying from now on his CFs will be released for a fee and they won't be available to everyone for free. I guess he's pissed off because Steilar criticized him, but there's no way in hell I will pay for a CF that another modder can do for free. Hope someone takes up the challenge and makes a Carmelo even better than his!

[agolden]

So, get this. I PM'ed AmaroWaade telling him I thought his Carmelo CF was awesome and that if he didn't release it publicly I hoped he would still share it with those who requested it privately. He sent me back a message saying from now on his CFs will be released for a fee and they won't be available to everyone for free. I guess he's pissed off because someone criticized him, but there's no way in hell I will pay for a CF that another madder can do for free. Hope someone takes up the challenge and makes a Carmelo even better than his!

Are you sure he wasn't joking?

[Brent72]

It certainly didn't sound like he was joking.

[agolden]

It certainly didn't sound like he was joking.

Well if he isn't joking I'm afraid that's against the rules of the forum - you can't sell your mods.

[Maverick]

So, get this. I PM'ed AmaroWaade telling him I thought his Carmelo CF was awesome and that if he didn't release it publicly I hoped he would still share it with those who requested it privately. He sent me back a message saying from now on his CFs will be released for a fee and they won't be available to everyone for free. I guess he's pissed off because Steilar criticized him, but there's no way in hell I will pay for a CF that another modder can do for free. Hope someone takes up the challenge and makes a Carmelo even better than his!

Oh! That's what he meant by the "ended the free sharing"? I thought he meant he'll just share it privately. So the Chinese sell their mods?

[buddaking]

So, get this. I PM'ed AmaroWaade telling him I thought his Carmelo CF was awesome and that if he didn't release it publicly I hoped he would still share it with those who requested it privately. He sent me back a message saying from now on his CFs will be released for a fee and they won't be available to everyone for free. I guess he's pissed off because Steilar criticized him, but there's no way in hell I will pay for a CF that another modder can do for free. Hope someone takes up the challenge and makes a Carmelo even better than his!

WOW, thanks for the heads up, i agree tho.i ain't paying for no cyberfaces as well. it nice to have but it not that serious, it not cool to preview a cycberface on here and then tell the people on here that it not free.

[wolfthebeer]

Of all the times you could have written this post in here, you chose to do it after he posted previews to arguably the best Carmelo Anthony CF ever?!? What the hell is wrong with you man?

LOL, you're absolutely right!

This is getting tiresome... I like to give my honest opinion about everything. Bearing that in mind, I am very careful with the wording so that I don't come out as disrespectful. For crying out loud, check my Stielar's Cut edition and see how many of Amarowade's faces I've chosen as the best for certain players.

Regarding Paul George and the comparison I made with Kidow's Paul George...once again, check out Stielar's Cut. I chose Amarowade's Paul George because he was more detailed. But certain aspects of Kidow's could have been useful on Amarowade's face, and vice versa. I think both modders are excellent and I'm grateful that people like them share their work with us.

As far as why I posted this now is concerned...it's because I think previews are shown to people so that those interested can express their opinion and help the modder fine-tune some details before the final release. This is common practice in other game modding forums. If in here the rule is only worship the preview or shut up, let me know.

I'm sure all this is just some misunderstanding of my post. However if Amarowade has understood completely my tone and my intent, and is still angry with my criticism, I promise not to write ever again in his thread.

the thread title never mention critic/feedback are welcome,it's suppose just to showcasing and sharing his works.
so next time better keep your thought for your self, look what you've done

[stielar]

To Amarowade

1. I think that punishinging everyone because you didn't like what one person said is unfair to say the least.
2. Once again, I apologize if I hurt your feelings.
3. I won't write again in this thread if it makes things better for you.
4. If deleting my previous comments will make you share your work again with the community then I will do so too, just say the word.


To everyone else:

1. I'm sorry that my comments led to all this. I have given my opinion both positive and negative to plenty of modders in the recent past with the intent to give an extra opinion so that they have one more piece of feedback in order to improve accordingly. I've tried to share my opinion with modders like Kidow, Frowardaxl83, Scarface, Bamz and a few other talented people around here, providing pictures some times, opinions, praise and criticism, albeit only in a constructive manner.
2. I hope that Amarowade will reconsider and keep providing the community with his wonderful faces.
3. Don't be angry at him for taking this decision to charge for his faces, we are all behind screens and keyboards and we have no idea what might be going on in his mind, in his personal life, maybe he had a tough day or something or maybe he misinterpreted my message. I think the best way is to show him that you would be grateful if he reconsidered.