Chandler or Howard

[DGenerate23]

the computer offered me Dwight Howard Hedo and reddick for Chandler Noah and Deng plus my 1st rounder in 2012 what set of players would you rather have? I'm playing as the bulls and have built a pretty solid team around DRose just not sure i wanna give up that much for a shot at Howard. I am 35-12 and my roster stands as

C T Chandler
PF J Noah
SF L Deng
SG R Hamilton
PG D Rose

6th PF T Gibson
SG K Korver
SF R Dupree
C O Asik
PG S Blake
PF Y Jianlian
PG S Livingston
SF J Butler

[Onisak]

Definetley keep the roster as it is... These "get a superstar" trades never quite work out .

[DGenerate23]

thats kinda why i was aksing and also why i got rid of boozer cause Chandler can give me 10 points and 5 rebounds a night plus play 10x better D

Edit: well i decided to play 2 games one with Chandler and one with Howard only changing out those players to see how my team reacted and came up with these roster stat lines so i think ill be staying with Tyson

Player Points Reb Assists Blocks
Rose 20 3 9
Hamilton 11 7 1
Deng 16 7 3
Noah 3 11 6 2
Chandler 32 1 1 5
Gibson 0 0 1 Hurt in first quarter didnt play rest of game
Korver 3 1 0
Dupree 6 9 3
Asik 7 2 1
Blake 2 1 3
Jianlian 2 1 0
Livingston 0 0 0

Rose 20 2 10
Hamilton 17 6 2
Deng 14 5 0
Noah 5 6 1 1
Howard 24 10 6 1
Gibson 4 6 4
Korver 4 3 1
Dupree 16 5 0
Asik 4 0 1
Blake 2 0 2
Jianlian 2 2 0
Livingston 0 1 1

[Andrew]

I'd pass on the trade too. It's difficult to pass on Dwight Howard but you're giving up a lot and getting a bad contract with declining trade value in Hedo.

[DGenerate23]

well i went ahead and passed on it and then hoped for the best that DH12 didnt make me regret it when we played later and thank god he didnt as both of them had very similar stat lines

T Chandler
16 points on 7-12 from feild 12 Rebounds 4 Assists and 2 Blocks

D Howard
18 points on 8-16 from feild 7 Rebounds 2 Assists and 3 Blocks