Nba 2k12 or Madden 12

[beau_boy04]

Nba 2k11 was great with Michael Jordan insertion and all, and it seems like Nba 2k12 is gonna surpass it. Anyways, when I read what Madden 12 has to offer I was amazed. Take a look at their franchise mode:

1. Expanded rosters and cut days
2. All-New rookie scouting system
3. All-new free agent bidding feature
4. More than 20 different player roles
5. Hot and cold streaks
6. Ability to change user controlled team
7. Trade future draft picks
8. Practice mode
9. Realistic injury frequency
10.Realistic injured reserve
11.Re-tuned simulation stats
12.Import draft class tuning
13.30 all-new draft classes
14.Realistic player profiles
15.Progression tuning
16.Franchise mode dynamic player performance
17.All-new tream re-sign logic
18.All-new cut dead weight logic
19. Weather tuning
20.All-new salary system
21.Re-tuned player retirements
22.Re-tuned player award logic
23.All-new player portraits for draft rookies
24.All-new depth chart logic
25.Edit players
26.All-new coaching impact
27.All-new interface

Can Nba 2k12 top that????? I think I'm buying both games. Which game is better in your opinion??? I think Madden has always been better than either Nba Live and Nba 2K

[Houndy]

NBA has had most of those for a while, NBA over Madden all day

[jaelove]

you're kidding right?

[Andrew]

I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest that if you want to play a basketball game, NBA 2K12 has it over Madden. Conversely, if you want some virtual football action, Madden is probably going to deliver the goods more than NBA 2K12.

Seriously, apples and oranges.

[benji]

How many forums did you ask this on?

[Mavs4Life]

Houndy & Andrew said what I wanna say.

"NBA over Madden all day"
"apples and oranges"

[shadowgrin]

All of you are idiots. It's no secret that if you want to play a realistic basketball videogame Madden is the way to go.

[Mavs4Life]

All of you are idiots. It's no secret that if you want to play a realistic basketball videogame Madden is the way to go.

No lie when I posted my comment I thought "shadow or benjji is gonna come in & give some words of wisdom"

[fjccommish]

Madden's franchise doesn't hold a candle to even NBA 2K11's franchise mode.

Madden 12 adds fake players to rosters during the pre-season. Some of these are contest winners, including teenage girls. The gamer has to cut players each week, sorting through some of these fake players that have high stats and bump off legit rookies.

In Madden 12, franchise CPU teams never trade with other CPU teams, and don't initiate trades with human controlled teams.

Scouting in Madden 12 is a farce. Send scouts to look at a QB. They come back showing his ratings for random stats like tackling. What pro scout would check a QB's tackling, but not report on his arm or accuracy?

Some of the franchise features in Madden are improved for 12. These include the sim-generated stats. But other features are still weak. The depth chart logic shows its ugly side in preseason games when a starting RB, like A. Peterson for the Vikings, ends up playing CB in the 3rd quarter of a preseason game.

Most of the new franchise features in Madden 12 are gimmicks and mini games like the ridiculous free agent bidding. These are added on top of a weak franchise mode which has been improved in some areas. NBA 2K11 had a fairly solid franchise mode that was miles ahead of Madden 11's, and miles ahead of Madden 12's. I expect 2K12 to include improvements.

[Smoove7]

If I am looking for a sports game, 2k12 is it hands down especially since it is going to be on PC and the community will be able to work their magic. Madden still continues to disappoint the hardcore sim player overall. Even though I am a bigger football fan than basketball, I will get 2k12 for the sim quality and what this community provides.

P.S.

2K make another football game PLEASE!!!