I thought it was good... not great, but good. The Superman AI was my main concern. I always get a hand up on a shooter....always, but the CPU always makes shots. I miss open shots, and get blocked even after I've gotten past my man. The game lacked game modes, and dynasty mode is basically just playing a bunch of games with the same team.
However, the good in the game helped me keep playing it. I like the hustle plays, and the freestyle passing. But my favorite thing to do on offense is move off-ball players and get 'em open for a shot. I also love the crowd atmosphere; I actually felt nervous on my first playoff game.
Player models are decent, and the gameplay is also great. Overall, I give it a 8/10.
Rant done.